This drug, and the other ‘triptans’, are molecular twins of serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine, or 5-HT), a brain chemical that governs mood. As 5-HT is released during migraine attacks, it is likely to play a key role. But giving 5-HT can also bring on a migraine. Triptans block serotonin receptors, and the action is supposed to be selective, with no effects on the other 15 or so 5-HT receptors in the body (related to blood-clotting, the lungs, the gastrointestinal tract and many others).

Initially, sumatriptan had an astonishing profile, reducing headaches in 81-86 per cent of patients (N Engl J Med, 1991; 325: 316-21; JAMA, 1991; 265: 2831-5). Since then, the ‘me-too drugs’ industry has has been busy churning out quantities of sumatriptan act-a-likes - zolmitriptan, naratriptan (Amerge®), rizatriptan, almotriptan, frovatriptan and eletriptan - in the form of injections, tablets and even a nasal spray.

Drugs that cause . . . headaches An embarrassing side-effect of this otherwise successful class of drugs is rebound headaches - when the medication becomes less and less effective until you get a headache when you go without it. More than a third of patients who initially found relief with sumatriptan suffered recurrent headaches, which the drug failed to reach (Eur Neurol, 1991; 31: 306-13). Some studies show that up to half the patients suffer rebound headaches.

Furthermore, many of the drug’s side-effects suggest that the supposedly selective action is not so selective after all, affecting other 5-HT-receptor sites.

Other problems include chest pain similar to angina (in 5-8 per cent of patients), largely because the drug, as a vasoconstrictor, narrows blood vessels, thereby restricting blood flow and raising blood pressure. Consequently, the drug is out of bounds for anyone with a heart problem.

Although the later generation - eletriptan, naratriptan and rizatriptan - claims to have sorted out these adverse reactions, eletriptan still has all the side-effects of sumatriptan (Neurology, 2000; 54: 156-63), including flushing, palpitations, nasal discomfort, eye irritation, visual disturbances and agitation.

Heart attack and stroke Individual case reports have been flowing in concerning patients with no known risk having either a heart attack or stroke within hours of taking a triptan. In Switzerland, one woman suffered a stroke within hours after injecting herself with two doses of sumatriptan; within 30 minutes of the second injection, her headache vastly increased, she began vomiting and experienced paralysis on the left side of her body before losing consciousness. In the US, when a woman’s headache severely worsened, a later CT scan showed that she had suffered a cerebral haemorrhage (Neurology, 2001; 56: 1243-4). Other case reports describe fatal heart attacks with the drug among those with no history of cardiovascular disease (Lancet, 1993; 341: 861-2).

Nevertheless, a recent review of the data for migraine sufferers found no association between triptan use and stroke or heart attack (Neurology, 2004; 62: 563-8). Even though a cohort study (a simple comparison of data) doesn’t count as a true scientific study like a prospective, randomised, double-blind trial, it will undoubtedly let the triptans off the hook for now.

Indeed, many researchers say that migraineurs naturally have a higher risk of stroke (Headache, 2003; 43: 90-5), although this is widely disputed (Headache, 2001; 41: 399-401). Also, triptans are contraindicated for patients with hemiplegic or basilar migraine because of possible cerebral vasoconstriction, indicating that doctors themselves believe there’s a link (Neurol Clin, 2001; 19: 1-21).

If you must take a triptan . . . Nicholas Bateman, of the Scottish Poisons Information Bureau, has compared all of the triptans and concluded that they are all much of a muchness. Although naratriptan seems to have fewer adverse reactions, there seems to be little to choose among them (Lancet, 2000; 355: 860-1). It also acts more slowly than the other triptans (see WDDTY vol 14 no 11 for alternatives for migraine).

What to do instead Try acupuncture, which has recently proved to be highly effective for patients with chronic headache (BMJ, 2004; 328: 744-7).